NOTICES
COPYRIGHT ROYALTY TRIBUNAL
[Docket No. CRT 85-3 85CA]
Notice Commencing Cable Copyright Rate Adjustment Proceeding
Tuesday, July 15, 1986
*25590 AGENCY: Copyright Royalty Tribunal.
ACTION: Notice commencing cable copyright rate adjustment proceeding.
SUMMARY: Turner Broadcasting Systems, Inc. has petitioned the Copyright Royalty Tribunal to initiate a cable copyright royalty adjustment proceeding. The Tribunal finds that TBS has a significant interest in the cable copyright royalty rates. The Tribunal announces commencement of a rate adjustment proceeding limited to the specific question presented by TBS, that is, whether justification exists to lower the copyright rate paid by certain cable systems for carriage of programs aired on WTBS, Atlanta, Georgia.
DATES: Cable copyright rate adjustment proceeding commences effective July 15, 1986. All parties must file a notice of appearance by August 1, 1986. Any objections to the appearance of any party must be filed by August 15, 1986. Replies to objections must be filed by August 20, 1986. The Tribunal will rule on participation on September 2, 1986. TBS must file its direct case on October 2, 1986.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:Edward W. Ray, Chairman, Copyright Royalty Tribunal, 1111 20th Street NW., Suite 450, Washington, DC 20036. (202-653- 5175).
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: On March 25, 1985, Turner Broadcasting Systems, Inc. (TBS) filed a petition pursuant to section 804 of the Copyright Act of 1976 (Act) to initiate a cable copyright royalty adjustment proceeding. TBS's petition requested that the Tribunal adopt a regulation which would permit those cable systems which currently pay copyright royalties for carriage of programs aired on WTBS, Atlanta, Georgia at a rate of 3.75% of gross receipts to pay instead at the applicable statutory rate (as adjusted for inflation). TBS did not request a general review of either the 3.75% rate or the syndicated exclusivity surcharge. Its request was limited solely to payment for additional carriage of programs on WTBS occurring due to FCC deregulation of its limitation of distant signal importation.
Section 804(a)(2) of the Act reads, "(D)uring the calendar years specified in the following schedule, any owner or user of a copyright work whose royalty rates are specified by this title, or by a rate established by the Tribunal, may file a petition with the Tribunal declaring that the petitioner requests an adjustment of the rate. The Tribunal shall make a determination as to whether the applicant has a significant interest in the royalty rate in which an adjustment is requested. If the Tribunal determines that the petitioner has a significant interest, the Chairman shall cause notice of this determination, with the reasons therefor, to be published in the Federal Register, together with *25591 notice of commencement of proceeding under this chapter."
In response to a motion filed by the Motion Picture Association of America, Inc. (MPAA), the Tribunal initiated an inquiry to ascertain whether TBS had the requisite "significant interest" to initiate a proceeding, and what procedures should apply to such a proceeding. Notice of Inquiry, 50 FR 23349 (June 3, 1985).
After consideration of the comments filed pursuant to the inquiry, the Tribunal decided to defer ruling on TBS's "significant interest," preferring to give all potentially interested parties the full extent of calendar year 1985 to reach either a negotiated settlement, or file additional petitions. Notice, 50 FR 43605 (October 28, 1985).
On December 31, 1985, the Tribunal received three petitions: a joint petition by the MPAA, American Society of Composers, Authors, and Publishers (ASCAP), Broadcast Music, Inc. (BMI), and SESAC, Inc. (collectively, A/B/S) to increase the 3.75% rate and the syndicated exclusivity surcharge; a petition by Major League Baseball, the National Baseball, the National Basketball Association and the National Hockey League to increase the 3.75% rate and the syndicated exclusivity surcharge; and a petition by the National Cable Television Association, Inc. (NCTA) to reduce the 3.75% rate.
The Tribunal issued another notice of inquiry, this time asking whether those who filed on December 31, 1985 has a significant interest in the cable copyright rates, and other procedural questions. Comments were due April 4, 1986; reply comments were due May 5, 1986. Notice of Inquiry, 51 FR 4414 (Febrary 4, 1986). Two one-month extensions of the comment periods were requested by the December 31 petitioners and granted by the Tribunal. [FN1] Order, March 28, 1986; Order, May 5, 1986. On May 2, 1986, the December 31 petitioners requested leave to withdraw their rate adjustment petitions. The Tribunal granted the request and determined that the only cable rate request which was still before it was the TBS petition. Order, May 5, 1986. "Significant Interest". In response to the Tribunal's June 3, 1985 Notice of Inquiry, the Tribunal received comments from TBS, the MPAA, A/B/S, NCTA, the Professional Sports Leagues, and United Video, Inc. and United Video Cablevision, Inc. (United Video). The National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) filed late-filed comments on December 31, 1985. Reply comments were filed by TBS, the MPAA and United Video.
FN1 TBS was not opposed to either of the extension requests.
In response to the Tribunal's February 4, 1986 Notice of Inquiry, the Tribunal received comments from NAB, the Canadian Claimants, United Video, TBS, the MPAA, NCTA, the Professional Sports Leagues, A/B/S, the Christian Broadcasting Network, Inc. (CBN) and USA Network. Reply comments were filed by the MPAA, TBS, and Major League Baseball.
Of those who commented, only TBS, the MPAA, and A/B/S directly addressed the question of "significant interest." (Although NAB stated that TBS' request required "an expansive reading" of the Act, and that it was troubled by "the kind of special, private relief TBS' request raises," it did not specifically comment on "significant interest.") TBS states that it is both an owner and a user of copyright works, and that it has a significant interest in the copyright rates by virtue of the fact that WTBS reaches a vast number of cable subscribers, and that programs aired on WTBS in 1983 accounted for a substantial percentage of all distant signal cable household viewing hours, according to Nielsen data.
The MPAA disagrees that TBS has a significant interest. It argues that TBS, as an owner of copyright works, is just one of dozens of copyright owner-claimants who receive royalties from the Tribunal. It further argues that Congress intended that a special finding of significant interest be made in order to avoid multiple rate adjustment proceedings. The MPAA offers as a minimum, that a category of copyright owner-claimants is necessary (such as Sports, Movies, Commercial Television, etc.) to meet the significant interest test.
A/B/S disagrees that TBS is a "user" of copyrighted works under Section 111. They argue that the word, "user" has a special meaning, that is, one who uses the copyrighted works pursuant to the compulsory license, i.e., a cable system. A/B/S agrees that TBS is a copyright owner, but argues that TBS is petitioning to lower the copyright rates, contrary to its true interests as a copyright owner. Therefore, A/B/S believes TBS does not have a "significant interest."
None of the parties has presented any research regarding the legislative history of the phrase, "significant interest." Nor is the Tribunal aware of Congress' specific intent. We, therefore, believe it is best to make determinations regarding "significant interest" cautiously, and on a case-by-case basis. The Tribunal concludes, first, that TBS is an owner, but not a user of copyrighted works, as Section 111 of the Act is intended. We agree with A/B/S that, in the context of the retransmission of copyrighted programs by cable systems, a broadcast station is a "middleman" between the owner of the works (in some cases, the broadcast station, itself) and the cable system. Therefore, TBS cannot be said to have a significant interest as a "user."
However, we find that TBS has a significant interest as an "owner" of copyrighted works. Annually, TBS is a copyright claimant before the Tribunal in three different program categories: in the Program Suppliers category as a syndicator of series and specials, in the Sports category, as an owner of two professional sports teams, and in the Commercial Television category, as the owner of station-produced programs on WTBS, Atlanta, Georgia. In the 1983 cable distribution proceeding, evidence was presented that WTBS was carried by approximately 1170 of the approximately 1570 Form 3 cable systems filing statements of accounts in 1983. Although, pursuant to the Tribunal's policy of encouraging settlements, the Tribunal does not know TBS' allocated copyright royalties within settled program groups, the Tribunal can reasonably conclude that TBS has a significant interest as a copyright owner in the cable royalty fund, and, therefore, in the cable royalty rate.
We disagree with the MPAA that the threshold should be at least an entire copyright program category. However, we agree with the MPAA that Congress did not intend every copyright owner or user, no matter how insubstantial his or her interest in the rate, to be able to initiate a proceeding, so that whether a petitioner has filed a copyright royalty claim or a statement of accounts is only the beginning of the analysis, not the end of it. But here, the Tribunal concludes that WTBS has the requisite "significant interest." Regarding A/B/S' assertion that TBS is acting contrary to its copyright interest, we recognize that TBS may have multiple corporate interests, but that appears to us to be more an argument on the substance of the issue raised by TBS than on the procedural question.
Burden of Proof--Participation--Scheduling. The Tribunal has determined that TBS shall have the burden of proof in this proceeding. We note that an opportunity was given during 1985 for any party to request a general review of the cable copyright rates. Three such petitions were filed, but they were subsequently withdrawn. We conclude that the existing cable copyright rates are presumptively reasonable. It is the burden of TBS to *25592 show that the regulation it requests should be adopted, and that such a regulation would not be discriminatory. The Tribunal will limit the evidence to the specific request of TBS. No expansion of the issues will be allowed. TBS' showing will proceed from the legal presumption that the 3.75% rate is reasonable as generally applied.
All parties who intend to participate in this proceeding shall file a notice of appearance by August 1, 1986. Any objections to the participation of any party shall be filed by August 15, 1986. Replies to objections shall be filed by August 20, 1986. The Tribunal will issue an order on September 2, 1986 on participation.
TBS shall file its written direct case on October 2, 1986. Further procedures and hearing dates will be announced at a later date.
Dated: July 9, 1986.
Edward W. Ray,
Chairman.
[FR Doc. 86-15851 Filed 7-14-86; 8:45 am]
Please refer to the IP Mall Copyright Royalty Tribunal homepage for details on this valuable resource.